|
Valuetronics Holdings is successfully transitioning its manufacturing focus from lower-margin Consumer Electronics (CE) to the higher-value Industrial and Commercial Electronics (ICE) sector. That's why the stock, trading at S$0.85, has gained 36% year-to-date (rising from ~S$0.62 at the start of 2025). |
The two reports, one from PhillipCapital (dated 17 Nov 2025) and one from UOB Kay Hian (11 Dec 2025), both take a positive view of Valuetronics, but they seem to differ in their degree of optimism and in the key factors they highlight.
Paul Chew, PhillipCapital analystPhillipCapital: Maintains an ACCUMULATE rating.
This recommendation means the analyst believes the stock is likely to outperform the market modestly or perform strongly but suggests buying gradually.
- Target Price: S$0.960.
- Share Price: S$0.850.
- Implied Upside: The target price implies a potential price appreciation of approximately 13% (S$0.960 vs S$0.850).
The total expected return, including dividends, is ~18%.
John Cheong, UOB KH analystUOB Kay Hian: Maintains a High Conviction BUY rating, implying strong confidence that the stock will achieve significant returns.
- Target Price: S$1.03.
- Share Price: S$0.85.
- Implied Upside: The target price implies a potential price appreciation of 21%.
Business Fundamentals
|
Category |
PhillipCapital |
UOB Kay Hian |
|
Performance |
• 1HFY26 operating earnings (EBIT) rebounded, rising 16.5%. Revenue was -3% y-o-y. |
• Notes improved order flows supported by external factors. |
|
Margins |
• Highlights a 2-percentage point expansion in gross margins driven by the ICE division and new customers. |
• Also notes the positive shift to more favourable margins from new customers. |
|
Growth Drivers |
• Driven by new customers in network infrastructure and PC cooling solutions; network infrastructure is now the largest category. |
• Driven by new ICE and CE customers (including one supplying a global entertainment conglomerate). |
Valuation
|
Category |
PhillipCapital |
UOB Kay Hian |
|
Valuation |
• Values the stock using a PE ratio of 13x for FY26e, noting this is still a discount to industry peers. |
• States the stock is highly attractive, trading at 12x FY27F PE, representing a 30-35% discount compared to Singapore peers. |
|
Cash Position |
• Emphasises the dividend yield of 5.4%, which is supported by a net cash balance of HK$1.1bn, equivalent to ~50% of the company's market value. |
• Highlights the large net cash position (HK$1.1b) also as ample room to enhance shareholder returns (e.g., through higher dividends or share buybacks). |

Key Risks and Catalysts
|
Category |
PhillipCapital |
UOB Kay Hian |
|
Main Risk |
• TrioAI venture, which is still loss-making and whose losses are widening. |
• Focuses on external tailwinds. |
|
Catalysts |
• Expects TrioAI losses to be contained due to a reduced stake in the company. |
• Easing trade tensions between the US and Vietnam, making Vietnam more competitive. |
| Differences Between the Two Reports |
The primary difference lies in the level of growth assumed and the primary focus of risk/reward analysis.
UOB KH appears more conservative regarding immediate revenue and profit growth compared to PhillipCapital, despite assigning a higher target price:
- Revenue Growth: PhillipCapital forecasts revenue of HK$1,785mn for FY26e (ending March 2026) and HK$1,926mn for FY27e.
UOB KH forecasts lower revenue for the same years: HK$1,650mn for FY26F and HK$1,726mn for FY27F. - Net Profit Forecasts: PhillipCapital forecasts HK$181.9mn for FY26e and HK$207.3mn for FY27e.
UOB KH forecast net profits are lower than Phillip's: HK$176mn for FY26F and HK$185mn for FY27F.
Key Catalysts
Differences in Time Horizon and Scenario Assumptions
|

