Excerpts from UOB KH report

Analyst: Llelleythan Tan

ComfortDelGro Corporation (CD SP)
Living With COVID-19

As Singapore moves on from the COVID-19 pandemic, we expect ridership to improve.

COMFORTDELGRO

Share price: 
$1.38 

Target: 
$1.73

Relaxation of COVID-19 measures has improved rail ridership while taxi passenger demand has surged. Singapore’s taxi industry is facing worsening demand-supply imbalance and stiff competition from ride-hailing competitors.

CD has also won a new public bus contract in Australia, expanding its footprint down under.

Maintain BUY with a slightly higher target price of S$1.73 (S$1.66 previously).


WHAT’S NEW
Transition to endemic living. From 26 Apr 22, Singapore’s authorities announced the easing of most of its social distancing measures. Some of the relaxed measures include the removal of group size limits, safe distancing no longer being mandatory and 100% of workers are now allowed to return to their respective workplaces.

Furthermore, Singapore’s international borders have fully reopened, welcoming back tourists. Backed by a population that is almost fully vaccinated, these favourable tailwinds would help underpin ComfortDelGro Corporation’s (CD) public transport and taxi earnings as mobility improves.

Improving ridership. SBS Transit experienced a strong recovery in rail ridership for May 22 (+56.8% yoy, +4.6% mom), forming 81% of pre-pandemic levels (May 19). We reckon that this is due to more office workers returning to office spaces and the removal of dine-in group size limits.

According to Land Transport Authority (LTA), passenger demand for point to point trips has gradually improved, albeit seeing slight dips due to COVID-19 outbreaks. Overall, we expect rail and taxi ridership to reach near pre-pandemic levels by 1Q23.

Expanded bus services down under. ComfortDelgro Corporation Australia has been awarded a six-year contract to solely operate public bus services in Northern Territory, Australia.

The contract areas cover a significant part of Northern Territory’s network which includes Darwin and Palmerston, with 170 buses operating across 180 bus routes. Expected to commence on 1 Jul 22, the contract is estimated to be worth around A$220m. Based on our estimates, this new bus contract would boost our 2022-24 PATMI estimates by 2-3%.

STOCK IMPACT
Domestic taxi: Demand-supply imbalance. Singapore is facing a shortage of taxi drivers to meet the surging demand. According to the LTA, the number of taxis and taxi driver’s vocational licence (TDVL) issued has shrunk since 2019.

taxis CDG4.22"For 2022, we have assumed an average utilised fleet of 8,300 (currently around 8,600) and a daily rental rate of S$90. We expect the taxi segment to post a 149% yoy increase in operating profit to S$46m as demand recovers."

-- UOB KH

CD’s taxi fleet has also been on a continuous downtrend along with Singapore’s total taxi fleet. After two years of underwhelming demand due to COVID-19 lockdowns, many taxi drivers have retired or opted for better-paying industries, reluctant to return to an industry that is facing elevated petrol prices and eroded earnings.

Before Singapore’s government raised the age limit for private hire driver’s licence to 30 years in Sep 20, younger drivers (below 30 years) tend to join the
ride-hailing industry as a short-term gig.

CD’s restrictive 30 years age requirement created an entry barrier for younger drivers to become new taxi drivers. Even after a price hike in Mar 22, CD has been largely unsuccessful in attracting new drivers or getting taxi drivers to return as many drivers have exited the industry completely.

Due to these structural changes, we reckon CD may have to increase/extend incentives further to retain/attract taxi drivers, dragging down profitability.

Supply to remain tight. Stiff competition from other ride-hailing operators has also caused many taxi drivers to make the jump. Through our channel checks, drivers in Singapore prefer CD’s ride-hailing competitors such as Grab and Go-Jek as they have lower daily rental rates and greater incentives, despite CD having the lowest commission rate.

Grab’s and Go-Jek’s cheaper daily rental rates make it easier and quicker for drivers to break even, a vital factor most drivers consider. A positive for CD taxi drivers is that they are allowed to pick up passengers via street hail while the rest cannot. However, as more passengers shift to online bookings, this advantage may be mitigated in the long run.

COMPARISON OF MAJOR RIDE-RAILING TRANSPORT OPERATORS

 

ComfortDelgro

Grab

Go-Jek

Comments

Rental (S$/day)

100-120

60-65

60-90

Excluding rental rebates/incentives.

Commission Rate

0% (Street fare)
4% (Comfort app)

20%

10%

Only CD drivers are allowed to street hail

Surge pricing

Slightly lower than Grab

Highest

Lowest

 

Street Hailing (Taxi) Market Share

~60%

NA

NA

Based on number of registered vehicles

Ride Hailing Market Share

~10-15%

~60-70%

~15-20%

Based on various reports

Petrol Discounts

~30% discount at CD’s depots

~29% discount from Caltex

~21% discount from Esso

Further discounts based on tiers.

Source: UOB Kay Hian, Grab, Go-Jek, CD, Primary Sources, Various Reports


EARNINGS REVISION/RISK
• We increase our 2022-24 PATMI forecasts by 2-3%, after accounting for new earnings contribution from the Northern Territory contract. We also did a sensitivity analysis against our utilised taxi assumptions.

For 2022, we have assumed an average utilised fleet of 8,300 (currently around 8,600) and a daily rental rate of S$90. We expect the taxi segment to post a 149% yoy increase in operating profit to S$46m as demand recovers. For every 100 increase/drop in utilised taxis from 8,300, it would increase/decrease our 2022 PATMI forecast and target price by 0.8% and S$0.01 respectively.

VALUATION/RECOMMENDATION
Llelleythan TanLlelleythan Tan• Maintain BUY with a higher 2022F PE-based target price of S$1.73 (S$1.66 previously), pegged to CD’s average five-year mean PE of 16.4x. The higher target price is due to higher 2022 earnings forecasts from the new Northern Territory contract.

SHARE PRICE CATALYST
• Bus tender contract wins, earnings-accretive overseas acquisitions.


Full report here


Share Prices

Counter NameLastChange
AEM Holdings3.840-0.010
Avi-Tech Electronics0.275-
Best World1.760-0.020
Broadway Ind0.118-
China Sunsine0.405-
DISA0.003-
Food Empire0.650-0.010
Fortress Minerals0.330-
Geo Energy Res0.3750.010
Golden Energy0.7800.005
GSS Energy0.046-
InnoTek0.470-
ISDN Holdings0.405-
ISOTeam0.100-
IX Biopharma0.126-
Jiutian Chemical0.0780.001
KSH Holdings0.3500.005
Leader Env0.056-0.002
Medtecs Intl0.140-0.002
Meta Health0.025-0.001
Nordic Group0.4800.005
Oxley Holdings0.149-
REX International0.235-
Riverstone0.635-0.010
Sinostar PEC0.170-
Southern Alliance Mining0.380-0.060
Straco Corp.0.405-
Sunpower Group0.260-
The Trendlines0.088-
Totm Technologies0.105-0.002
UG Healthcare0.195-
Uni-Asia Group0.830-0.005
Wilmar Intl4.1200.020
Yangzijiang Shipbldg1.4200.020

NextInsight RSS

rss_2 NextInsight - Latest News

Online Now

We have 2785 guests and no members online